Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Amran Gowani's avatar

Hey Wil, I liked this one and it was paced well. Few small thoughts I had:

1) Does Andy need to be named? The punch at the end was a little lost on me because I'd already forgotten who he was. Maybe just go with "best friend"?

2) I think there's more opportunity to probe on "This was it. I would have no other first kiss." You do an awesome job with describing all the things that didn't happen, and how crazy expectations would obviously never be met, but perhaps to Meg's points you could just come out and have the narrator say "I was disappointed" or "I blew it" or whatever you think Walt's feeling. Of note: I remember being disappointed in my first ever real "French kiss" because it happened so abruptly with someone I didn't even really know or like. Kind of a bummer even 30 years later.

3) The end feels a little rushed. Not sure exactly what it needs, but maybe another beat or two would capture the emotion.

All in all, I dug it. These are just some gut reaction thoughts.

Expand full comment
Meg Oolders's avatar

Me again.😊Here's my sidebar comment, reconstituted for your reader community:

I went back and read your Intro chapter after I had an epiphany about what was missing for me from today's installment - the fabulous voice you gave us in your introduction!!!! Where's that guy?? Grown up, wiser, wittier, finally loved by someone Walt!!! He's telling the whole story, right? Am I right?

Because you could keep some of the distance from "feelings" in chapter one if your plan is to attack this Wonder Years style, where we get to watch the coming-of-age action but are guided by the emotional tone of the voiceover. And if that's the case, you just need more voiceover. A play-by-play from the guy who played the game. Yes? NO? Maybe?

Expand full comment
17 more comments...

No posts